Gotcha. I've found a few awesome leathery BPALs, but if what you've tried so far has gone Yankee-Candle on you, I doubt these would be much different. (Still: Iago (leather, vetiver, black musk) or Hatta (balsam, brown leather, cinnamon) -- Hatta is one of the ones sold through the Century Guild gallery, while Iago is general-catalog. I also like Severin (leather, black tea, Earl Grey) but it's discontinued and harder to find, and I think you'd probably find it too scented-candle on you. There's also Rogue (leather, hemp rope, rosin) which is also general-catalog.)

Body chemistry! Such a weird and personal thing.